Review: 'Playing for Keeps'

(EW.com) -- The most interesting thing about Gerard Butler is that he has spent his career as a Hollywood star avoiding any roles that even remotely resemble the one that actually made him a star.

In "300," Butler played the Spartan King Leonidas as an epic hero archetype with the volume turned up to 11, all nonstop speeches and granite abs. Since then, Butler has veered between two personalities: The brutish sociopaths of "Gamer" and "Law Abiding Citizen," and the brutish-but-supposedly-lovable cads of "The Ugly Truth" and "The Bounty Hunter." (The lone exception came in Ralph Fiennes' little-seen "Coriolanus," where Butler gave good Shakespeare as a Leonidas-esque tormented warlord.)

Neither of these personalities is particularly appealing, but in "Playing for Keeps," Butler plays a slightly older riff on his cad persona, and the results are initially promising. It helps that the actor has gotten steadily scruffier in his last few movies — indeed, one of the best parts of the movie is that Butler realistically looks like he rolled out of bed right before every take. In "Playing," he plays George, a former professional soccer player-turned-failed entrepreneur with dreams of becoming a sportscaster. George is spending time in a lilywhite suburb in order to spend time with his son (freckle-faced Noah Lomax), and to cozy up to his ex (Jessica Biel, frowning in the doorway). In an effort to prove himself as a parent, George winds up coaching his son's soccer team.

In the early scenes, Butler makes George an endearing wreck of a man, and you're set up to expect a sports-movie redemption for him: "Bad News Bears" with a brogue. But the movie forgets about the soccer team, and focuses much more attention on the soccer moms. Judy Greer, Catherine Zeta-Jones, and Uma Thurman play desperate-housewife variations — a crying divorcee, a seductive ex-sportscastress, a daffy trophy wife. None of them can keep their hands off George. They flirt with him; they open their souls to him; they try to find him a job; at one point, one of them climbs uninvited into his bed and starts stripping off her clothes.

It could be good fodder for an old-fashioned sex comedy — and each of the actresses does her best with her one allotted character trait. But "Playing for Keeps" takes place in a tonally incoherent universe, constantly shifting between rom-com farce and mawkish family drama. The central question of the movie becomes: Can George triumph over his inability to stop hot women from throwing themselves at him? Grade: C-

See original story at EW.com.

CLICK HERE to Try 2 RISK FREE issues of Entertainment Weekly

© 2011 Entertainment Weekly and Time Inc. All rights reserved.

0

Comments »

• Print
• Email
• More sharing

Click Here to Comment on this Article

Tagged : No tags for this article

Sex & Relationships: The Beauty Of A Good Marriage

Denmark wins Eurovision Song Contest

Headlines Newsview all

Cop who 'came back from the dead' after getting shot by Boston bombing suspect is ready to get back to work

By Associated Press PUBLISHED: 21:11 EST, 19 May 2013 | UPDATED: 22:36 EST, 19 May 2013 Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority Officer Richard Donahue still has a bullet in his leg ...

Obama discusses race, fatherhood with Morehouse grads. Says he feels a 'special obligation' to help less-fortunate African-Americans

By Daily Mail Reporter PUBLISHED: 19:30 EST, 19 May 2013 | UPDATED: 22:35 EST, 19 May 2013 President Barack Obama gave the commencement address at Morehouse College in Atlanta, Georgia, ...

Massive tornadoes hit Kansas and Oklahoma as Midwest and Southern states are placed on high alert

At least one person reported dead in Shawnee, Oklahoma in decimated trailer parkOklahoma governor declares state of emergency in 16 counties By Daily Mail Reporter ...

Hilarious moment husband caught cheating wife - as her boyfriend escapes from window

By Daily Mail Reporter PUBLISHED: 20:50 EST, 19 May 2013 | UPDATED: 21:38 EST, 19 May 2013 In a stunning example of a soap opera come to life, a video ...

Nathan Walsh: Spectacular paintings of Big Apple and Chicago that are so realistic even seasoned residents would look twice

By Daily Mail Reporter PUBLISHED: 18:08 EST, 19 May 2013 | UPDATED: 21:01 EST, 19 May 2013 A British artist has captured the hustle and bustle of the Big Apple ...

Activists bristle as India cracks down on foreign funding of NGOs

NEW DELHI — Amid an intensifying crackdown on nongovernmental groups that receive foreign funding, Indian activists are accusing the government of stifling their right ...

Elliot Morales: Chilling moment Greenwich Village gay hate killing suspect laughed and boasted about 'murder' minutes after attack

Elliot Morales, 33, was charged with second-degree murder as a hate crime, menacing and two counts of possession of a weapon in a Manhattan court ...

Latest Blog

Pippa Middleton: Duchess of Cambridge's sister steps out for Verity Evetts wedding

Marriage of Verity Evetts, Pippa's close friend and Royal Wedding guestPippa, 29, arrived at church in Hampshire with banker Tom Kingston, 34She made an entrance wearing a £370 feminine lacy dress by Tory Burch By Claire Ellicott PUBLISHED: 12:30 EST, 19 May 2013 | UPDATED: 19:51 EST, 19 May 2013 It was a typical society wedding, complete with members of the aristocracy and the obligatory...

0 comments

Man killed and four people injured after Newark house is set alight by 'gas explosion'

Blast happened yesterday at house on road in Newark, NottinghamshireLocals were asked to remain indoors and close windows to avoid fumesSearches of property ongoing to confirm if anyone else is inside house By Mark Duell PUBLISHED: 13:43 EST, 19 May 2013 | UPDATED: 19:49 EST, 19 May 2013 A man was killed and four other people were injured last night in a gas explosion which...

0 comments

Hofstra University hostages: Somber graduation ceremony holds moment of silence for slain classmate Andrea Rebello

Many of the grads wore white ribbons in remembrance of their classmateRebello, 21, a junior at the Long Island university was shot dead at 2:20am on Friday in the off-campus home she shared with her twin sisterA masked male intruder named Dalton Smith, was also shot dead after holding Rebello, her twin Jessica, and others hostagePolice were alerted when their...

0 comments

The RSPCA tried to ruin my life, says top barrister: A decade of accusations - and a £1m legal bill to defend his good name

 Jonathan Rich, defended hundreds of people against RSPCA over 20 yearsFriend of Dawn Aubrey-Ward, 43, an RSPCA inspector turned whistleblower She accused the charity of destroying her character She was found hanged at her home this month By Liz Hull PUBLISHED: 19:33 EST, 19 May 2013 | UPDATED: 19:33 EST, 19 May 2013 A leading barrister yesterday claimed he had been forced to stop working...

0 comments

Hofstra University hostages: John Kourtessis tells of seeing Andrea Robello shot dead

Andrea Rebello, a junior at Hofstra, was shot dead at 2.20am on Friday in her Uniondale sorority houseA masked male intruder, today named as Dalton Smith, was also shot deadThe victim's twin, Jessica, was also held hostage along with her boyfriendPolice were alerted when their friend Shannon Thomas was allowed out to get cash from an ATM and immediately called...

0 comments

UKIP poll surge as one in five voters say they'd back them as major parties suffer

Support for the UK Independence Party has reached a record 19 per centBoth Labour and the Tories losing ground, according to poll resultsSupport for Nigel Farage's party up despite this week's protestsLord Mandelson today branded UKIP the 'UK isolation party' By Sam Webb PUBLISHED: 07:31 EST, 19 May 2013 | UPDATED: 07:42 EST, 19 May 2013 Support for the UK Independence Party has grown...

0 comments

Conservatives 'are out of control' over Europe says former chancellor Lord Howe as poll shows surge in support for UKIP

Lord Howe says David Cameron has open a political 'Pandora's Box'He said row over lack of an EU referendum was a 'new, almost farcical, low'UKIP polls record 20 per cent support, behind Tories on 29 per centMr Cameron was also dragged further into row over 'swivel-eyed loons'The PM was accused of using the insult himself last yearLord Feldman denies making...

0 comments

Divorced British father 'in custody battle' arrested after French police find bodies of his son and daughter with their throats cut

Five-year-old girl and 10-year-old boy found dead in father's apartmentBelieved to be first weekend father was allowed sole custody of childrenPolice alerted by mother who bumped into him in lobby on SaturdayHe was arrested by police on suspicion of murder today By Peter Allen PUBLISHED: 06:24 EST, 19 May 2013 | UPDATED: 07:28 EST, 19 May 2013 A divorced British father involved in a bitter...

0 comments

Misty and Larry Shaffer secretly loses 150lbs for soldier husbands return

Misty Shaffer set herself a goal to lose weight while her husband was awayShe kept her weight loss secret by not taking pics below the shoulderHusband Larry  didn't recognize her in the crowd at the airportIncredible welcome home surprises: daughter has grown up and the family have a new house too By James Daniel PUBLISHED: 13:11 EST, 18 May 2013 | UPDATED: 07:21 EST,...

0 comments

Facebook study: Lives of Mr and Mrs Average charted online show how women discuss TV at 44 and men lose interest in their careers at 30

The unique study follows the interests of 1million Facebook users  Shows the sexes become interested in different topics at different ages By Becky Evans PUBLISHED: 07:18 EST, 19 May 2013 | UPDATED: 07:18 EST, 19 May 2013 Ever felt like you have nothing in common with your partner and conversation is a struggle? Well the root of the problem may simply lie in the...

0 comments

Imran Khan condemns killing of senior member of his reforming party after she was gunned down outside her home

Former cricketer 'shocked and saddened' by death of Zara Shahid HussainBlames rival party MQM - but they strongly deny any involvement By Daily Mail Reporter PUBLISHED: 04:26 EST, 19 May 2013 | UPDATED: 06:52 EST, 19 May 2013 Campaign: Imran Khan, chair of the Movement for Justice (PTI) party, has condemned the killing of a senior party member Former cricketer Imran Khan has condemned the...

0 comments

Is this nurse serving 30 years for murders that never happened? Compelling new evidence suggests 'Angel of Death' is innocent

Colin Norris was jailed in 2008 for four murders and an attempted murderThe prosecution at his trial said the victims all died from hypoglycaemiaIt was claimed blood sugar condition almost never arises spontaneouslyProsecution suggested Norris injected patients with insulin to trigger itBut new studies show hypoglycaemia in elderly patients for other reasonsSix others died from condition in Norris' hospitals but...

0 comments

Police launch murder investigation after man, 31, is shot dead in Brighton street

The man died in hospital after the attackHe was gunned down at about 11.30pm last nightPolice say shooting is 'not believed to be random' By Sam Webb PUBLISHED: 03:30 EST, 19 May 2013 | UPDATED: 06:46 EST, 19 May 2013 A murder investigation has been launched following the shooting of a man last night, police said.The 31-year-old man was shot on the junction of Church...

0 comments

World's most dramatic city as you've never seen it before: Stunning timelapse video of Dubai show hustle and bustle of life around skyscrapers and mosques

PUBLISHED: 05:22 EST, 19 May 2013 | UPDATED: 06:43 EST, 19 May 2013 It is the playground of the rich where ostentatious wealth is flaunted, the skyscrapers reach the skies and the sun never seems to stop shining.Tourists pack the boats as they float past the towering buildings that stand beside the turquoise-blue waterways. Now an amazing timelapse video of Dubai takes viewers on...

0 comments

Google tax avoidance row: Internet giant accused of 'scandalous' tax avoidance scheme by whistleblower

Barney Jones said Google diverts British profits through Ireland to Bermuda Former executive said company 'pulled the wool over the eyes' of HMRCAdds to mounting pressure on Google over its tax affairs Company says all sales contracts go through its low-tax Ireland office Last year, paid just £7.3million in corporation tax on UK turnover of £3billion By Becky Evans PUBLISHED: 03:23...

0 comments

That's quite a mark-up! 25-bedroom Grade I-listed mansion built by famed architect Sir John Soane goes on sale for £18m after being bought for just £2.5m a decade ago

Stunning property in Buckinghamshire was completed in 1797 with gardens designed by Sir Edwin LutyensTen main bedrooms and nine bathrooms with a stable house which boasts a spa and swimming pool'It could be labelled as one of England's greatest architectural masterpieces' say estate agents By Daily Mail Reporter PUBLISHED: 06:11 EST, 19 May 2013 | UPDATED: 06:33 EST, 19 May 2013 A stunning country estate...

0 comments

Comment on: Review: 'Playing for Keeps'